RQ said:
In real world driving, there is probably a 4 to 8 second time period in
slowing down and stopping for a red light where the energy of a 3000 lb
car slowing from say 60k to 30k is converted to watts and stored in that
4 to 8 second time frame. That sounds like a hell of a jolt to me.
I have made the following calculation for a panic stop: Assume that you
have a vehicle of 1000 kg (2200 lbs) and you are going to decelerate it
from 100 km/h (62 mph) to a stop in 50 m at -8 m/s^2 (about 0.82 g).
This requires 400,000 J (watt-seconds) of energy and takes about 3.5
seconds.
The Toyota Prius uses a 274 V NiMH battery with a capacity of about
7 Ah (3 hour rate). If you wanted to dump all that energy into the
battery, you'd have 115.2 kW over the 3.4 seconds, or 420 A. Compared
to the battery capacity, this is a lot. I seem to recall (but can't
cite) a number that only 10 to 20% of the braking energy is recaptured
by the regenerative system, and that figure would seem to be a more
reasonable rate to recharge that battery.
The Prius battery does have several thermistors embedded in it, a
forced-air cooling system, and its own computer to decide how it will
be charged. While I agree that charging at a too-high rate is not
good for any battery, this "battery" is not just a box of chemicals.
It can stop charging itself if the rate is too high. (Also, the target
state-of-charge in most hybrid cars is not 100%; it's usually somewhere
between 50% and 80%, so there will always be someplace to dump some of
the energy when braking.)
Another clue is that Toyota warrants the battery and hybrid components
for 8 years or 100,000 miles. The 2004 and up Priuses use the same
battery as the 2001-2003 Priuses, but use it more extensively to get
better fuel economy, so Toyota must be comfortable that the battery
will last at least that long.
Matt Roberds