Maker Pro
Maker Pro

Snake Oil: Stealth wallpaper keeps company secrets safe

G

Guy Macon

Jan 1, 1970
0
(Snake Oil, anyone?)

| Stealth wallpaper keeps company secrets safe
|
| August 04
| New Scientist Magazine
| http://www.newscientist.com/news/print.jsp?id=ns99996240
|
| A type of wallpaper that prevents Wi-Fi signals escaping
| from a building without blocking mobile phone signals has
| been developed by a British defence contractor. The
| technology is designed to stop outsiders gaining access to a
| secure network by using Wi-Fi networks casually set up by
| workers at the office.
|
| It is the work of moments for an employee to connect a
| paperback-sized Wi-Fi base station to a company network.
| That person can then wander around the office with their
| laptop while remaining wirelessly connected to the internet.
|
| But it is also the work of moments then for an outsider to
| breach that company's computer security using the Wi-Fi
| connection. Unless the Wi-Fi base station is protected by
| security measures that most amateur users would not bother
| to set up, it gives anyone up to 100 metres away the chance
| to bypass the corporate firewall and wirelessly hack
| straight into the network.
|
| Until now, the only way to ensure people are not illicitly
| gaining access to company secrets has been to turn offices
| into a signal-proof "Faraday cage", by lining the walls with
| aluminium foil, and using glass that absorbs radio waves in
| the windows. This ensures all electromagnetic emissions are
| absorbed, but it also means that no one can use a cellphone
| in the building.
|
| So the UK's telecoms regulator, Ofcom, has paid BAE Systems,
| formerly British Aerospace, to come up with an answer for
| firms who are becoming increasingly worried about the
| threat. BAE Systems has based its solution on the secret
| "stealth" technology that it uses to hide military radars.
| The covering, called Frequency Selective Surface (FSS)
| sheeting, is used to shroud radar antennas on warships or
| aircraft.
|
|
| Copper coated
|
|
| Solid metal antennas normally give a very strong reflection
| to enemy radar scanners. To hide them, FSS sheeting can be
| electrically set to allow through only the precise frequency
| the antenna wants to transmit and receive, while absorbing
| all other frequencies including those of the incoming radar.
|
| BAE's anti-Wi-Fi wallpaper is made from a
| 0.1-millimetre-thick sheet of kapton, the same plastic used
| to make flexible printed circuit boards in lightweight
| portable gadgets like camcorders. The kapton is coated on
| each side with a thin film of copper.
|
| On one side most of the copper is removed, leaving a grid of
| copper crosses. On the other side, matching crosses, turned
| through 45 degrees, are etched away ¬- leaving a film of
| copper with a grid of cross-shaped holes. BAE says that by
| carefully changing the size of the crosses and their
| spacing, the sheet can pass precisely defined frequencies,
| while blocking all others.
|
| But they are not revealing how the military technology works
| except to say it is a little like an optical diffraction
| grating creating interference to destroy certain light
| frequencies. "We have developed formulae for this, which we
| aren't going to give away," says project leader Kevin
| Mitchell.
|
|
| On or off
|
|
| Ofcom engineers have confirmed to New Scientist that the
| wallpaper can block Wi-Fi at 2.4, 5 and 6 gigahertz, while
| letting through GSM and 3G cellphone signals, plus emergency
| service calls.
|
| Better still, the filtering can be switched on or off if
| diodes are connected between the copper crosses. When a
| current is fed through the diodes, all frequencies are
| blocked. Switching them off "opens" the panel to let mobile
| and emergency signals through.
|
| The wall covering can be mass produced at relatively low
| cost. A square metre will cost about £500: peanuts to big
| business.
|
| BAE is now working on a transparent, ultra-thin version for
| windows. William Webb, Ofcom's R&D chief, says: "With this
| new technology, signals can be shared securely and go where
| they need to go, and no further."
|
|
| Barry Fox
 
J

John Larkin

Jan 1, 1970
0
(Snake Oil, anyone?)

| Stealth wallpaper keeps company secrets safe
|
| August 04
| New Scientist Magazine
| http://www.newscientist.com/news/print.jsp?id=ns99996240
|
| A type of wallpaper that prevents Wi-Fi signals escaping
| from a building without blocking mobile phone signals has
| been developed by a British defence contractor. The
| technology is designed to stop outsiders gaining access to a
| secure network by using Wi-Fi networks casually set up by
| workers at the office.
|
| It is the work of moments for an employee to connect a
| paperback-sized Wi-Fi base station to a company network.
| That person can then wander around the office with their
| laptop while remaining wirelessly connected to the internet.
|
| But it is also the work of moments then for an outsider to
| breach that company's computer security using the Wi-Fi
| connection. Unless the Wi-Fi base station is protected by
| security measures that most amateur users would not bother
| to set up, it gives anyone up to 100 metres away the chance
| to bypass the corporate firewall and wirelessly hack
| straight into the network.
|
| Until now, the only way to ensure people are not illicitly
| gaining access to company secrets has been to turn offices
| into a signal-proof "Faraday cage", by lining the walls with
| aluminium foil, and using glass that absorbs radio waves in
| the windows. This ensures all electromagnetic emissions are
| absorbed, but it also means that no one can use a cellphone
| in the building.
|
| So the UK's telecoms regulator, Ofcom, has paid BAE Systems,
| formerly British Aerospace, to come up with an answer for
| firms who are becoming increasingly worried about the
| threat. BAE Systems has based its solution on the secret
| "stealth" technology that it uses to hide military radars.
| The covering, called Frequency Selective Surface (FSS)
| sheeting, is used to shroud radar antennas on warships or
| aircraft.
|
|
| Copper coated
|
|
| Solid metal antennas normally give a very strong reflection
| to enemy radar scanners. To hide them, FSS sheeting can be
| electrically set to allow through only the precise frequency
| the antenna wants to transmit and receive, while absorbing
| all other frequencies including those of the incoming radar.
|
| BAE's anti-Wi-Fi wallpaper is made from a
| 0.1-millimetre-thick sheet of kapton, the same plastic used
| to make flexible printed circuit boards in lightweight
| portable gadgets like camcorders. The kapton is coated on
| each side with a thin film of copper.
|
| On one side most of the copper is removed, leaving a grid of
| copper crosses. On the other side, matching crosses, turned
| through 45 degrees, are etched away ¬- leaving a film of
| copper with a grid of cross-shaped holes. BAE says that by
| carefully changing the size of the crosses and their
| spacing, the sheet can pass precisely defined frequencies,
| while blocking all others.
|
| But they are not revealing how the military technology works
| except to say it is a little like an optical diffraction
| grating creating interference to destroy certain light
| frequencies. "We have developed formulae for this, which we
| aren't going to give away," says project leader Kevin
| Mitchell.
|
|
| On or off
|
|
| Ofcom engineers have confirmed to New Scientist that the
| wallpaper can block Wi-Fi at 2.4, 5 and 6 gigahertz, while
| letting through GSM and 3G cellphone signals, plus emergency
| service calls.
|
| Better still, the filtering can be switched on or off if
| diodes are connected between the copper crosses. When a
| current is fed through the diodes, all frequencies are
| blocked. Switching them off "opens" the panel to let mobile
| and emergency signals through.
|
| The wall covering can be mass produced at relatively low
| cost. A square metre will cost about £500: peanuts to big
| business.
|
| BAE is now working on a transparent, ultra-thin version for
| windows. William Webb, Ofcom's R&D chief, says: "With this
| new technology, signals can be shared securely and go where
| they need to go, and no further."
|
|
| Barry Fox


I just finished reading "Skunk Works" by Ben Rich, who led development
of the stealth fighter. It has a radar cross-section about the same as
a 0.5" diameter ball bearing. To sell it to the brass, they went to
the Pentagon and rolled ball bearings on peoples' desks, and told them
they could have a jet plane with the same radar reflectivity.

John
 
G

Gareth

Jan 1, 1970
0
Guy said:
(Snake Oil, anyone?)

Why do you think this is snake oil? Do you think that it is not
possible to have a thin material which will block only certain
frequencies, or do you think the hole idea of blocking Wi-Fi signals is
pointless?

Gareth.


--
 
R

Rich Grise

Jan 1, 1970
0
Norm said:
Could be a tuned thing, possibly like a diffraction grating.

Possibly....
--------------
| But they are not revealing how the military technology works
| except to say it is a little like an optical diffraction
^^^^^^^^^^^
| grating creating interference to destroy certain light
^^^^^^^
| frequencies. "We have developed formulae for this, which we
| aren't going to give away," says project leader Kevin
| Mitchell.
----------------
Rich
 
R

Rune Christensen

Jan 1, 1970
0
3G mobile phones and Wi-Fi are very close to each other in frequency. 2.1
and 2.4 GHz so the filtering of the shield should be very narrow if 3G
mobile phones should be able to connect to the outside but wi-Fi shouldn't.

Maybe the crosses are working just like passive repeaters for the mobile
frequencies 900MHz, 1800MHz and 2.1GHz
 
G

Guy Macon

Jan 1, 1970
0
Gareth said:
Why do you think this is snake oil? Do you think that it is not
possible to have a thin material which will block only certain
frequencies, or do you think the hole idea of blocking Wi-Fi signals is
pointless?

I don't think that any "wallpaper" will have a steep enough
slope between the pass band and the reject band to do what they
say it will do.

I don't think that any solution that ignores doors, windows,
heating ducts, lighing fixtures, etc. will be able to work
as an effective RF shield.

I don't think that they can make a transparant version, and if
they could, I think that it will be very hard to tie the shielding
in the window glass to the shielding in the walls.

I don't believe that any diffraction grating can "pass precisely
defined frequencies, while blocking all others."

I don't think that Frequency Selective Surfaces are new.
 
R

Rich Grise

Jan 1, 1970
0
Guy Macon said:
I don't think that any "wallpaper" will have a steep enough
slope between the pass band and the reject band to do what they
say it will do.

You might be surprised. According to their description, it sounds like
some stuff I read about microwaves, cavity resonators, and stuff, where
a tuned slot serves as some kind of high-Q coupling, or something like
that.
I don't think that any solution that ignores doors, windows,
heating ducts, lighing fixtures, etc. will be able to work
as an effective RF shield.

Good Point.
I don't think that they can make a transparant version, and if
they could, I think that it will be very hard to tie the shielding
in the window glass to the shielding in the walls.

This depends on if you can get transparent conductive material.
Tying them together shouldn't be a problem - look at those tape
alarm things.
I don't believe that any diffraction grating can "pass precisely
defined frequencies, while blocking all others."

Not a diffraction grating, no, but tuned slots, yes.
I don't think that Frequency Selective Surfaces are new.

Not this decade, anyway. :)

Cheers!
Rich
 
F

Frithiof Andreas Jensen

Jan 1, 1970
0
(Snake Oil, anyone?)

I believe it works as stated - it's an Engineering Problem not a Physics
Problem; Engineering problems can be solved by throwing Ressources at them!

Bae are well into the defense business and they contract a large contingent
of researchers into many different "basic physics areas" with millitary
utility. If one dug into the "paper-trail", I would speculate that this
application is a spinoff of research into meeting either Tempest or Stealth
requirements with some material and manufacture research added to it.

i.e:

Bae Engineer: "For that idea to work, we need to be able to make a wallpaper
of lossy dipoles, maybe several layers of, and control the orientation as
well as the placement, maybe in three dimensions with volume production";

Bae Customer (handing over vast sum of money): "Make It So" ;-)
 
G

Guy Macon

Jan 1, 1970
0
Rich Grise said:
This depends on if you can get transparent conductive material.
Tying them together shouldn't be a problem - look at those tape
alarm things.

I don't believe that that would do the job. let's say that you had
a perfect faraday shield on the walls, doors, floors, etc but with
an unshielded window. Now you put a faraday shield over the window.
for it to be an effective shield, it would have to connect to the
wall shielding at many points along the perimeter. and those contact
points would have to have a low impedance at the frequency that you
wish to block. I have worked inside shielded rooms many times, and
I have never seen one that was built with some sort of wallpaper
added to existing construction - even starting with a windowless
room. Shielded rooms have special doors with contact points along
the perimeter.

If, on the other hand, these snake oil salesmen could show that they
are able to build an effective add-on faraday shield that stops wi-fi,
cellphones, etc., a good RF EE could probably design an antenna for
the inside, am electronic filter/amplifier with the proper passband,
coax through the wall, and an external antenna. Thayt should work.
 
M

Martin Brown

Jan 1, 1970
0
Guy Macon said:
(Snake Oil, anyone?)

| Stealth wallpaper keeps company secrets safe
|
| August 04
| New Scientist Magazine
| http://www.newscientist.com/news/print.jsp?id=ns99996240
|
| A type of wallpaper that prevents Wi-Fi signals escaping
| from a building without blocking mobile phone signals has
| been developed by a British defence contractor. The
| technology is designed to stop outsiders gaining access to a
| secure network by using Wi-Fi networks casually set up by
| workers at the office.

It is certainly possible to do this kind of thing. Though to be honest I
would much prefer to have them make a wallpaper that blocks mobile phone
transmissions whilst allowing Wi-Fi to operate.

I have never been disturbed by W-Fi users bellowing into their equipment
"I'm on the train", "in the theatre", "in the library" or "in the
restaurant".

The thing that is novel is that they have managed to make a band reject
tuneable design in a thin layer that allegedly works so well. Most other
solutions use a generic Faraday cage.

Regards,
 
J

John Larkin

Jan 1, 1970
0
I believe it works as stated - it's an Engineering Problem not a Physics
Problem; Engineering problems can be solved by throwing Ressources at them!

Bae are well into the defense business and they contract a large contingent
of researchers into many different "basic physics areas" with millitary
utility. If one dug into the "paper-trail", I would speculate that this
application is a spinoff of research into meeting either Tempest or Stealth
requirements with some material and manufacture research added to it.

i.e:

Bae Engineer: "For that idea to work, we need to be able to make a wallpaper
of lossy dipoles, maybe several layers of, and control the orientation as
well as the placement, maybe in three dimensions with volume production";

Bae Customer (handing over vast sum of money): "Make It So" ;-)

BAE is one of my customers, working on an aircraft radar test thing.
The guys I work with are very nice and very smart.

John
 
R

Robert Baer

Jan 1, 1970
0
Guy said:
(Snake Oil, anyone?)

| Stealth wallpaper keeps company secrets safe
|
| August 04
| New Scientist Magazine
| http://www.newscientist.com/news/print.jsp?id=ns99996240
|
| A type of wallpaper that prevents Wi-Fi signals escaping
| from a building without blocking mobile phone signals has
| been developed by a British defence contractor. The
| technology is designed to stop outsiders gaining access to a
| secure network by using Wi-Fi networks casually set up by
| workers at the office.
|
| It is the work of moments for an employee to connect a
| paperback-sized Wi-Fi base station to a company network.
| That person can then wander around the office with their
| laptop while remaining wirelessly connected to the internet.
|
| But it is also the work of moments then for an outsider to
| breach that company's computer security using the Wi-Fi
| connection. Unless the Wi-Fi base station is protected by
| security measures that most amateur users would not bother
| to set up, it gives anyone up to 100 metres away the chance
| to bypass the corporate firewall and wirelessly hack
| straight into the network.
|
| Until now, the only way to ensure people are not illicitly
| gaining access to company secrets has been to turn offices
| into a signal-proof "Faraday cage", by lining the walls with
| aluminium foil, and using glass that absorbs radio waves in
| the windows. This ensures all electromagnetic emissions are
| absorbed, but it also means that no one can use a cellphone
| in the building.
|
| So the UK's telecoms regulator, Ofcom, has paid BAE Systems,
| formerly British Aerospace, to come up with an answer for
| firms who are becoming increasingly worried about the
| threat. BAE Systems has based its solution on the secret
| "stealth" technology that it uses to hide military radars.
| The covering, called Frequency Selective Surface (FSS)
| sheeting, is used to shroud radar antennas on warships or
| aircraft.
|
|
| Copper coated
|
|
| Solid metal antennas normally give a very strong reflection
| to enemy radar scanners. To hide them, FSS sheeting can be
| electrically set to allow through only the precise frequency
| the antenna wants to transmit and receive, while absorbing
| all other frequencies including those of the incoming radar.
|
| BAE's anti-Wi-Fi wallpaper is made from a
| 0.1-millimetre-thick sheet of kapton, the same plastic used
| to make flexible printed circuit boards in lightweight
| portable gadgets like camcorders. The kapton is coated on
| each side with a thin film of copper.
|
| On one side most of the copper is removed, leaving a grid of
| copper crosses. On the other side, matching crosses, turned
| through 45 degrees, are etched away ¬- leaving a film of
| copper with a grid of cross-shaped holes. BAE says that by
| carefully changing the size of the crosses and their
| spacing, the sheet can pass precisely defined frequencies,
| while blocking all others.
|
| But they are not revealing how the military technology works
| except to say it is a little like an optical diffraction
| grating creating interference to destroy certain light
| frequencies. "We have developed formulae for this, which we
| aren't going to give away," says project leader Kevin
| Mitchell.
|
|
| On or off
|
|
| Ofcom engineers have confirmed to New Scientist that the
| wallpaper can block Wi-Fi at 2.4, 5 and 6 gigahertz, while
| letting through GSM and 3G cellphone signals, plus emergency
| service calls.
|
| Better still, the filtering can be switched on or off if
| diodes are connected between the copper crosses. When a
| current is fed through the diodes, all frequencies are
| blocked. Switching them off "opens" the panel to let mobile
| and emergency signals through.
|
| The wall covering can be mass produced at relatively low
| cost. A square metre will cost about £500: peanuts to big
| business.
|
| BAE is now working on a transparent, ultra-thin version for
| windows. William Webb, Ofcom's R&D chief, says: "With this
| new technology, signals can be shared securely and go where
| they need to go, and no further."
|
|
| Barry Fox

Funny; i recently saw an ad for that wallpaper; i think in EE Times.
No details given except to say that cell phones work.
The only way to keep a secret safe, is to make sure only *ONE* person
knows it (!!!!!) and that it never gets written down or otherwise
transmitted in any form...
 
F

Frithiof Andreas Jensen

Jan 1, 1970
0
message
BAE is one of my customers, working on an aircraft radar test thing.
The guys I work with are very nice and very smart.

Been My experience too - I hope that part of the message made it through.

But they *do* a lot of wierd, Star Treck'ish, stuff - which is probably why
they attract really gifted research engineers in the first place. A lot of
it probably comes to nothing, yet the occasional Big Win pays for it all.
Thats also my impression b.t.w.
 
G

Guy Macon

Jan 1, 1970
0
Frithiof Andreas Jensen said:
Been My experience too - I hope that part of the message made it through.

But they *do* a lot of wierd, Star Treck'ish, stuff - which is probably why
they attract really gifted research engineers in the first place. A lot of
it probably comes to nothing, yet the occasional Big Win pays for it all.
Thats also my impression b.t.w.

Interesting... Sounds like the kind of outfit I would like to work for.
 
Top