Maker Pro
Maker Pro

Aluminum oxide insulator safety precautions?

J

John

Jan 1, 1970
0
I don't trust the phase-change crayon stuff. It's likely to leave air
I totally agree.

I've gotten the Aavid Ultrastick phase-change goop down to what I
thought was about 1-2mils after clamping. It flowed like water when
hot but never got any thinner than that. And that's with belleville
washers, etc.

The grease I'm using now starts at that thickness (if I put it on with
care) and then just gets thinner with pressure. Their thermal
conductivity specs are pretty close so I'm going with the grease.

I'm using the Wakefield 126 Series stuff now but Dow TC-5022 looks
great. Several times the conductivity of the 340 grease. I have a
sample on order and will see if there's any difference. At these
thicknesses though, I can probably use mayonnaise and still be OK. :)

John
 
J

John

Jan 1, 1970
0
We do hard anodize and as I recall it's not real expensive. It's
I just got back my first 1mil hardcoat anodized heat sinks and was
pretty surprised to see that the black I ordered was only a light
gray. Oh well.

But, that's one tough coating!

I checked it with a 10x loupe and the hardcoat on the main mounting
surface of the heat sink seems "cracked". Kind of like the surface of
a really old oil painting. Lots and lots of tiny cracks that form the
hardcoat into tiny crystals/plates. It doesn't flake though and I
don't see this effect on any of the vertical pins coming off the base
plate of the sink.

Do you know if this effect is typical or a possible problem?

John
 
J

John Larkin

Jan 1, 1970
0
I just got back my first 1mil hardcoat anodized heat sinks and was
pretty surprised to see that the black I ordered was only a light
gray. Oh well.

Some alloys anodize a nicer black than others.

But, that's one tough coating!

Get a dvm and a pair of sharp probes. Try to measure ohms as you poke
the heatsink. If it's good anodize, you will have to apply real
muscle, grinding the probes into the coating, before you see
continuity.


I checked it with a 10x loupe and the hardcoat on the main mounting
surface of the heat sink seems "cracked". Kind of like the surface of
a really old oil painting. Lots and lots of tiny cracks that form the
hardcoat into tiny crystals/plates. It doesn't flake though and I
don't see this effect on any of the vertical pins coming off the base
plate of the sink.

Do you know if this effect is typical or a possible problem?

It does usually have character, partly because of the surface finish
before anodizing. Sometines we specify "heavy etch, 1.0 mil hard black
anodize". The etch smooths the surface and removes any tiny burrs.

But if your coating passes the probe test, it's probably fine.


John
 
J

John Larkin

Jan 1, 1970
0
I totally agree.

I've gotten the Aavid Ultrastick phase-change goop down to what I
thought was about 1-2mils after clamping. It flowed like water when
hot but never got any thinner than that. And that's with belleville
washers, etc.

The grease I'm using now starts at that thickness (if I put it on with
care) and then just gets thinner with pressure. Their thermal
conductivity specs are pretty close so I'm going with the grease.

I'm using the Wakefield 126 Series stuff now but Dow TC-5022 looks
great. Several times the conductivity of the 340 grease. I have a
sample on order and will see if there's any difference. At these
thicknesses though, I can probably use mayonnaise and still be OK. :)

Yeah, any sort of flowable grease will probably be about the same. I
suspect that the thermal filler materials don't help much; what's
important is that it's not air and that it squashes down very thin.

Vaseline maybe? Axle grease? Grey Poupon?

John
 
R

Rich Grise

Jan 1, 1970
0
Yeah, any sort of flowable grease will probably be about the same. I
suspect that the thermal filler materials don't help much; what's
important is that it's not air and that it squashes down very thin.

Vaseline maybe? Axle grease? Grey Poupon?
Nah, Grey Poupon has those little ground-up seeds.

But what about RTV? It's silicone, and you wouldn't even need bolts! ;-)

I've found that Vaseline makes dandy vacuum grease, and it's almost
impossible to clean it off any surface it's been applied to, especially
where you _don't_ want it. ;-)

Cheers!
Rich
 
J

John Larkin

Jan 1, 1970
0
Nah, Grey Poupon has those little ground-up seeds.

But what about RTV? It's silicone, and you wouldn't even need bolts! ;-)

Epoxy is good. If you load it with glass beads, you don't even need an
insulator.

John
 
J

John

Jan 1, 1970
0
Get a dvm and a pair of sharp probes. Try to measure ohms as you poke
the heatsink. If it's good anodize, you will have to apply real
muscle, grinding the probes into the coating, before you see
continuity. [snip]
It does usually have character, partly because of the surface finish
before anodizing. Sometines we specify "heavy etch, 1.0 mil hard black
anodize". The etch smooths the surface and removes any tiny burrs.

But if your coating passes the probe test, it's probably fine.

OK, I'm feeling better about the coating. With a 10x loupe, the
hardcoating looks very much like a windshield after being
shattered...lots of tiny "platelets" sitting on the surface of the
metal, all adjoining each other. But, I grabbed a pair of pretty
sharp probes and went to town. I had to very visibly dig/scratch into
the coating to get any reading.

Would the heavy etch possibly have any impact on the case-to-sink
thermal impedance (by increasing surface roughness)?

We have several 6-32 holes for mounting the MOSFETs. I'm thinking it
can't etch away enough metal to affect the tightness of those, could
it? I guess it depends on how big a burr the etching could remove.

John
 
J

John

Jan 1, 1970
0
Epoxy is good. If you load it with glass beads, you don't even need an
LOL, brilliant. The bead size could even be spec'd to get the desired
dielectric strength.

John
 
J

John Larkin

Jan 1, 1970
0
LOL, brilliant. The bead size could even be spec'd to get the desired
dielectric strength.

John

Check out Cataphote.

John
 
J

John

Jan 1, 1970
0
LOL, brilliant. The bead size could even be spec'd to get the desired
I can't believe I can buy 2nm size nanospheres! :)
Cataphote doesn't seem to have a web site but I did find other
companies. Just an amazing selection of sizes and materials!

John
 
J

John Larkin

Jan 1, 1970
0
I can't believe I can buy 2nm size nanospheres! :)
Cataphote doesn't seem to have a web site but I did find other
companies. Just an amazing selection of sizes and materials!

John

http://www.cataphote.com/


They make the bulk glass beads used for retroflectors. Here in
California, at every stop sign they also lay down a STOP stencil in
the street, spray on white paint, the toss on handsfull of Cataphote
beads to make the lettering reflective. Some blow away and leave
little sparkles in the neighborhood here and there, until the rain
washes them away.

John
 
R

Rich Grise

Jan 1, 1970
0
Get a dvm and a pair of sharp probes. Try to measure ohms as you poke
the heatsink. If it's good anodize, you will have to apply real
muscle, grinding the probes into the coating, before you see
continuity. [snip]
It does usually have character, partly because of the surface finish
before anodizing. Sometines we specify "heavy etch, 1.0 mil hard black
anodize". The etch smooths the surface and removes any tiny burrs.

But if your coating passes the probe test, it's probably fine.

OK, I'm feeling better about the coating. With a 10x loupe, the
hardcoating looks very much like a windshield after being
shattered...lots of tiny "platelets" sitting on the surface of the
metal, all adjoining each other. But, I grabbed a pair of pretty
sharp probes and went to town. I had to very visibly dig/scratch into
the coating to get any reading.

Would the heavy etch possibly have any impact on the case-to-sink
thermal impedance (by increasing surface roughness)?

We have several 6-32 holes for mounting the MOSFETs. I'm thinking it
can't etch away enough metal to affect the tightness of those, could
it? I guess it depends on how big a burr the etching could remove.

If you want it flatter, get some diamond grit and lap it. ;-)

Otherwise, I wouldn't worry if you've got good heatsink goo.

Cheers!
Rich
 
J

John Larkin

Jan 1, 1970
0
Get a dvm and a pair of sharp probes. Try to measure ohms as you poke
the heatsink. If it's good anodize, you will have to apply real
muscle, grinding the probes into the coating, before you see
continuity. [snip]
It does usually have character, partly because of the surface finish
before anodizing. Sometines we specify "heavy etch, 1.0 mil hard black
anodize". The etch smooths the surface and removes any tiny burrs.

But if your coating passes the probe test, it's probably fine.

OK, I'm feeling better about the coating. With a 10x loupe, the
hardcoating looks very much like a windshield after being
shattered...lots of tiny "platelets" sitting on the surface of the
metal, all adjoining each other. But, I grabbed a pair of pretty
sharp probes and went to town. I had to very visibly dig/scratch into
the coating to get any reading.

Would the heavy etch possibly have any impact on the case-to-sink
thermal impedance (by increasing surface roughness)?

We have several 6-32 holes for mounting the MOSFETs. I'm thinking it
can't etch away enough metal to affect the tightness of those, could
it? I guess it depends on how big a burr the etching could remove.


The etch does improve the burr situation. Even better is to
clamp-mount the transistors.

The hard anodize does tend to gunk up threads tapped into the
heatsink. If the hole is a bit countersunk before it's tapped, you're
less likely to have burrs, and you can chase the threads with a tap if
necessary, although that's real hard on taps. I think you can get
oversize taps, which allow for the buildup from anodizing and don't
need chasing.

We've done thousands of power amps with transistors bolted or clamped
to anodized heatsinks, up to 200 volts, and only had a few problems,
mostly from burrs or post-anodize dings as I recall.


John
 
J

John

Jan 1, 1970
0
If you want it flatter, get some diamond grit and lap it. ;-)
The Wakefield stuff we have seems to be working out very well. We
also ordered a sample of the Dow TC5022 (I think) goop and they're
sending us a 1kg can!

I'm going to have to go out and give some of this stuff away. We'll
never use that much in 100 years. :)

John
 
J

John

Jan 1, 1970
0
The etch does improve the burr situation. Even better is to
You read our minds. If we make any more of these things, we're going
to switch over to clamping.


Oversize taps...that sounds familiar. So far, with the couple of
sinks we've tested, it only took using a machine screw to chase the
threads.


Currently, the holes are countersunk before tapping. So far, so good.
I hate having to grab the loupe and check each sink though. I guess
if we don't find any problems after checking a bunch, we'll just
assume all is OK until one of the sinks tests hot. Hmm...actually,
it'll take less time to 100% check the batch rather than swap out a
heat sink that has a burr. :)

John
 
J

John Larkin

Jan 1, 1970
0
Thats' the site I tried. It's only an entrance to someone's search
portal.

Hmmm, yes, it is strange. They *used* to have a real web site.

John
 
Top