A New Method Introduced to Verify Quantum Chips Are Computing Correctly

about 2 weeks ago by Misha Khan

The world of electronics development has progressed further than ever before. With those progressions, we see more traditional technologies gradually replaced with new innovations.

In this article, we'll be exploring a specific upgrade to one of the most common pieces of technology used today, computer systems. Their replacement? Quantum computers. 

MIT and Google, in partnership, have introduced a method that strongly suggests the higher efficiency of quantum computing in comparison to the computational capabilities of traditional computers. The main aim of the research partnership was to analyze complex computations that have been accurately verified by quantum chips when comparing them to classical computers. 


Developing a Protocol to Verify Quantum Chip Efficiency

The computations in the research study were conducted through quantum chips using quantum bits (known as “qubits). The classical binary bits of 0 or 1 were represented by quantum chips called the “quantum superposition” of both states. In that way, quantum chips were found capable of solving problems that are considered impossible for traditional computer systems.

The MIT and Google researchers also demonstrated a protocol that validated if a NISQ chip (Noisy Intermediate Scale Quantum), also developed by their team, has performed all the required quantum operations. They validated the performance of the protocol with a complex quantum problem that was running on a custom quantum photonic chip. Jacqueus Carolan from the Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (EECS) and the Research Laboratory of Electronics (RLE) shared, “Our technique provides an important tool for verifying a broad class of quantum systems. Because if I invest billions of dollars to build a quantum chip, it sure better do something interesting.”


A system developed by MIT and Google to verify quantum chips.

A custom system developed by MIT and Google researchers to validate methods for verifying quantum chips. Image Credit: Mihika Prabhu via MIT.


Research Methods

The method developed by the researchers used the following two techniques:


Divide and Conquer

The researchers used the “divide and conquer” approach in one of two techniques for the experiment. The “Divide and Conquer” approach is present at the core of their new protocol known as “variational quantum unsampling”.

The "Divide and Conquer" technique involves breaking down the output quantum state into chunks. They unscrambled it layer by layer instead of processing the entire thing in one shot. The inspiration behind this technique originated from neutral neural networks. Neural networks are known to solve problems by using multiple computation layers. Therefore, the research team developed a novel protocol called “quantum neural network – QNN”.

Each layer of QNN represented a set of quantum operations. This took less time when compared to the task of processing at one time. This approach caused the breakdown of problems into sub-slots and it ultimately helped the researchers solve complex problems more efficiently. 

Under this approach, traditional techniques of silicon fabrication were used for developing a 2-by-5-milimeter NISQ chip with more than 170 control parameters. In an effort to manipulation the photon path, adjustable circuit components were used. An external component injected into the chip was also used for the generation of photons’ pairs at specific wavelengths. Photons change their path creating an interference with each other by means of chip’s phase shifters. Through this processing, a random quantum output state is produced, which is a representation of what will happen during computation. An array of photodetector sensors connected externally was used for the output measurement. 


Output Processing: Using the Divide and Conquer Approach

The obtained output was sent to the QNN i.e. quantum neural network. The complex optimization techniques were therefore used to separate the noisy output. These techniques pointed out the single photon’s signature present among scrambled ones. After this step, the unscrambling step comes in. It identifies the single photon from a group and validates the circuit operations that will return it back to its known input state. This is how operations matching took place on all the subsequent layers that were at the base of computation. 


Boson “unsampling”

The second technique used by the researchers was “boson sampling”. This approach generally applied to photonic chips. This technique involved optical components and phase shifters that were used for manipulating a set of input photons into a different quantum of output photons superposition. The main objective behind this task was a probability calculation stating a certain input state was going to match to a certain output state. 


Google's Sycamore chip.

Google's 'Sycamore' quantum processor that associated them with 'quantum supremacy'. Image Credit: Erik Lucero.


Existing Problems with Classical Computation

Fullscale quantum computers actually need millions of qubits and so far, that isn't feasible. Keeping this problem in mind, researchers started working on the development of “Noisy Intermediate Scale Quantum (NISQ)” chips that comprise of about 50 to 100 qubits.

Though, it isn't an entirely efficient strategy, it's just enough to demonstrate “quantum advantage”. This implies that NISQ chips can actually solve algorithms that traditional computers are incapable of solving. The two approaches used by the researchers were computing samples, it is impossible for a traditional computer to compute them. This is mainly due to the reason that photons show unpredictable behavior photons. Therefore, the use of NISQ chips has suggested that their computation is quick and efficient. 


Applying the Quantum Verification Method to "Physical World" Problems

Hopes for the future potential of the research is to contribute to the ongoing effort of making the quantum verification process as quick and efficient as possible. The research team also hoped that the findings would apply to other problems in the physical world. 

The new methods demonstrated by MIT and Google were dedicated to verifying the fact that quantum chips can deliver efficient performance and accurate computation. They succeeded in demonstrating that a quantum system could perform complex operations that traditional computers weren't capable of.