Maker Pro
Maker Pro

Understanding LED brightness (mcd and viewing angle)?

lizgraham

Jul 3, 2009
1
Joined
Jul 3, 2009
Messages
1
Hello, I am trying to decorate a reception tent with Chinese lanterns, however to save on costs I plan on hooking up a 10mm LED bulb to a battery (someone suggested a CR 2032 3v batteries) and tossing the lights into the lanterns. However, the mcd value ranges and I don't know what it means on a scale of it would blind my guests to they are eating in the dark. I basically need the equivalent brightness of a Christmas light or a bit brighter. If you know what LED I should use, or what’s used in Christmas lights, please let me know.

Thanks for any input.
 

BobK

Jan 5, 2010
7,682
Joined
Jan 5, 2010
Messages
7,682
mcd is a measure of light intensity. You can have two LEDs, one with a viewing angle of 120 degrees and another with a viewing angle of 20 degrees, both of which put out the same amount of light, and the second one will have a much higher mcd rating. Which means it will make a small spot of intense light vs a large spot of less intense light.

Lumens, on the other hand, is a measure of the total light output by the LED.

What you want for the chinese lanterns is an LED with a large viewing angle, so that the light is directed at all of the paper shade. Look for one with a wide angle (120) and high Lumens.

Bob
 

dave9

Mar 5, 2017
1,188
Joined
Mar 5, 2017
Messages
1,188
If they are the only source of illumination, they'll be eating in the dark. I'd need to know the specific LED used and have a proper datasheet for it to make a good approximation of lumen output at drive current (with a CR2032 or whatever you settle for, IMO CR2032 is only enough for decoration purposes, not area lighting), but even with multi-chip 10mm LEDs (which will need PCB heatsinking for reasonable life - running just one night, I couldn't guess if they'd last or burn out w/o heatsinking), you'd probably end up under 10 lumens per LED, and definitely so powered by 1 x CR2032 which just can't sustain the necessary current.

As BobK already explained, MCD is just intensity, determined by the shape of the plastic lens molded into the LED casing. Even 120' would be rather narrow for a traditional lantern shape. In theory you might be able to use a belt sander and sand down the lens dome on an LED (or buy some with flat ends), then polish to near optically clear to get a beam closer to 180', but in practice that would be a pain in the *** to do for more than a small # of LEDs.

For this reason I would go with bare chip LEDs instead, then under-driven enough they won't need a heatsink.

If they are the only illumination, everyone has their own ideas about what is bright enough to eat but I'd think you're going to want (very) roughly 100 lumens per square meter, or even a lot more if the light is cast evenly around lanterns so it is going everywhere instead of just directed down at a table.

It seems very impractical, I think I would consider a single battery pack with much higher capacity cells then run wire between all the lanterns, maybe use a deep cycle 12V marine battery. LEDs are comparatively efficient but it still takes a fair amount of current to light up an area for more than a few minutes, yet you didn't mention the amount of area.
 

kellys_eye

Jun 25, 2010
6,514
Joined
Jun 25, 2010
Messages
6,514
Get some 'straw hat' type LEDs and some cheap ping pong balls.

Fit the LED and battery inside the ball for a nice diffuse light effect that won't blind anyone.
 
Top