Connect with us

TCP TruDim dimmable CFLs

Discussion in 'Lighting' started by Travis Evans, Nov 20, 2011.

Scroll to continue with content
  1. Travis Evans

    Travis Evans Guest

    Has anyone heard of these? They look quite interesting.
    https://www.1000bulbs.com/category/tcp-trudim-dimmable-cfl-compact-fluorescents/

    Spec sheet: https://www.1000bulbs.com/pdf/TCP-TruDim-specs.pdf

    While the manufacturer doesn't appear to indicate whether these are less
    prone to lifespan/electrode sputtering problems as other dimmable CFLs,
    they do boast a number of performance improvements.

    I ordered a couple of the 23-watt 1450-lumen 4100K ones, which I
    received today. After performing the manufacturer-recommended 2-hour
    "burn-in" at full power (actually, I ran them for about 6-7 hours just
    for good measure), these are my first impressions after playing with
    them for a bit:

    * I'm not sure about the "dimming to 2%" claim. It's not clear what
    exactly this "2%" figure refers to, but it doesn't appear to refer to
    lumen output (or else the dimmest level should be about 29 lumens).
    However, it does dim to a level that appears dimmer than a 40-watt
    incandescent at full power, perhaps approaching that of a 25-watt
    incandescent (rough guess). This should provide an adequate dimming
    range for the majority of applications, I think. At this point, power
    consumption is about 5-6 watts per lamp (around 30-35 VA at a PF of
    around .33 (PF at full power is around .7)).

    * The dimming curve does appear to be excellent. Many dimmable CFLs
    don't change very noticably in brightness over the upper portion of the
    dimmer control; these do. With a 100-watt incandescent operating on the
    same dimmer beside a 23-watt TruDim CFL, the apparent brightness with
    dimming appears to roughly match that of the incandescent, as claimed.

    * While it's difficult to tell if the warm-up period is noticably
    shorter than most other CFLs I've used, my wattage meter reveals the
    operation of the "accelerated warm-up overdrive" feature, with wattage
    consumption up to 30W over the first minute or two of operation before
    settling back down to around 23-24W once the lamp has reached operating
    temperature.

    * As claimed, I do not notice any 60- or 120-Hz flicker even at the
    minimum brightness level as I do with other dimmable CFLs I've used.

    * I like how they ramp up or down smoothly in brightness over about half
    a second when the dimming control is adjusted quickly. I have some
    Utilitech dimmable spirals bought at a local Lowes that tend to flicker
    fairly wildly as the control is moved.

    * The point at which the dimmer is adjusted too low and the lamps
    extinguish and begin cycling is sharply-defined. In contrast, the
    Utilitech and Sylvania dimmable CFLs I've used transition smoothly from
    dimmed output to flickery end-only glow, making it a lot less
    straightforward to determine where the "minimum safe dimming level" is.

    I am a little bothered by the repeated cycling when the dimmer is
    accidentally turned down too far. It seems like it would be better if
    the electronics could detect this and stop trying to start the tube
    after a couple of unsuccessful attempts.

    So far, these seem like pretty nice CFLs with reasonable prices, as far
    as dimmables go. Time will tell how well they do in the longevity area.
     
Ask a Question
Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?
You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.
Electronics Point Logo
Continue to site
Quote of the day

-