Connect with us

Low Pass Filter Testing

Discussion in 'Electronic Design' started by [email protected], Sep 3, 2012.

  1. Guest

    Hi,

    I am reading the following paper to do some Low pass and Anti Aliasing Filter testing

    http://edge.rit.edu/content/P08050/public/PDF Documentation/Testing Strategy.pdf

    My question is as follows

    The paper says that I should Oscilloscope to see the results that are demonstrated in figure 2 and 3. How is that possible? The figures are plots of gain vs frequency!

    I can see the amplitude getting diminished if I constantly increasing the frequency of the signal to 1KHz. I am probing across the Capacitor.

    So, Am I right to say that when signal starts to reduce in amplitude that thats where the gain will be zero db.

    Erica
     
  2. On Mon, 3 Sep 2012 11:53:15 -0700 (PDT), the renowned
    Gain is 0dB when the input voltage = the output voltage.

    Gain (in dB) is 20*log10(Vout/Vin)

    You can check that with the oscilloscope.


    Best regards,
    Spehro Pefhany
     
  3. miso

    miso Guest

    That is kind of a poorly worded document. They mention to use a scope,
    but show the output of a digital signal analyzer (DSA). Most DSAs have
    microHZ resolution these days, so testing the filter on an analyzer
    could be done.

    If you look at the curve, the response is a bandpass. With 0dB gain
    (input equals output) at 2mHz, you are testing the high pass portion of
    the filter. The high pass corner is around 300mHz. The low pass corner
    is around 40Hz.

    Of course the anti-aliasing is a function of the low pass portion of the
    bandpass filter.

    In the millihz range, these tests I assume are done on a digital scope.
    I'd set it up dual channel and watch input and output. According to the
    response shown, they would be nearly 180 degrees out of phase.
     
  4. Guest

    Hi,

    Figure 1 : http://img528.imageshack.us/img528/5866/84368707.png

    Figure 2 : http://img651.imageshack.us/img651/6795/bewfile0.jpg


    Low pass filter values: R = 10,000 ohm ; C = 273pF

    Input signal ( sine wave ) Freq = 3.2 Hz, Amp = 50mV peak to peak

    Figure 2 shows the comparision between the input sine wave ( yellow trace) vs blue trace across the capacitor.


    Figure 1 shows the circuit diagram.

    Question:

    Why I am not seeing a reduced or attenuated or filtered continous sine wave across the capacitor. Why I am seeing samples of the input sine wave. I am using oscilloscope DS1102D.

    Thanks

    Erica
     
  5. Guest

    I am talking about the capacitor connected between ground and pin 3 of the ADC.
     
  6. Jamie

    Jamie Guest

    It's my guess you are reading something else, also connected to the
    capacitor, which ever one it is.. ?

    It looks like digital noise and if so. If could be emanating from the
    following circuit, there after.

    Run that test with nothing connected to the cap other than the minimum.

    Jamie
     
  7. What's the RC 'corner frequency' of 10k and 270pF? Anywhere near
    3.2Hz?
    As Jamie said unhook the A/D and see what it looks like then. What's
    the switch doing in the circuit? Do you have ground on the 'scope
    hooked to your circuit?
    Rip up everything but the signal generator and R-C and make that work
    properly! I'd like to see a plot of amplitude and phase shift vs
    frequency. (Crank up the amplitude on the signal generator 50mV is
    wimpy.)

    George H.
     
  8. Jamie

    Jamie Guest

    What you're seeing is most likely normal.

    For some ADC's, the input has internal activities acting directly on
    the input. This means you must take care to insure the reference you
    put there is not being shared elsewhere, otherwise you'll be getting
    this noise there, too.

    Usually the specs on the ADC chip give you a specific requirement as
    what should be there.

    After looking at that ADC chip, I don't see why there should be that
    much noise there. That does seem odd. You may want to be causes with
    your grounds and path ways.

    Digital can propagate through the board like capacitor couplings. Try
    moving your ground clip of the probe doing the ADC input measuring
    directly on the common of the chip and use the 10:1 mode. If that
    clears things a bit, you need to work on getting better grounding.. Try
    not to daisy chain to many items on a single ground path.



    Jamie
     
  9. miso

    miso Guest

    First of all, you have switched topics, right? Was the original question
    answered?

    I got the impression the first question dealt with some COTS machine
    that you are trying to calibrate. That is, and established design that
    is in production. Now are we dealing with a design question?

    There is plenty I don't like about this design. The RC filter depends on
    the impedance of the mux and driving impedance of the signal sources. Is
    this ADC buffered on the inputs? If not, then all bets are off because
    your signal source isn't stiff.
     
  10. qrk

    qrk Guest

    The corner freq of your low pass is around 58kHz (1/(2piRC)). Your
    3.2Hz signal won't be attenuated.

    The ADC, what is the input doing? Is it a buffered input or is it a
    switching input. Many ADCs sample the input, switching a capacitor
    between the input and internal circuitry. An ADC which samples the
    input needs to have a low impedance source which can handle a nasty
    load. Your RC circuit on the input is anything but low impedance.
     
  11. What does this mean?
     
  12. Les Cargill

    Les Cargill Guest

  13. miso

    miso Guest

    The other issue is I'm calling the cascade of a LPF and HPF a bandpass,
    which could add to the confusion since it is colloquially correct, but
    not technically.

    An anti-aliasing filter is not a reconstruction filter. If you want to
    get picky, the reconstruction filter needs an inverse sinc shape in the
    passband, but often that is done in software.
     
  14. Les Cargill

    Les Cargill Guest

    It's pretty close - the impulse responses of the three should be
    related in a very predictable manner .

    True enough. That's the canonical form; sometimes implementations
    deviate ( and will have aliasing ).

    Oversampling yadda yadda...
     
  15. Nah. A "reconstruction" filter is not an "anti-alias" filter. One
    goes before an ADC, one goes after a DAC.

    After thinking about it, I think he meant that (since it is in the
    first Nyquist zone) it is the high side rejection aspect that is
    important for anti-aliasing. That's true in this case, as it is in
    the first Nyquist zone. It isn't generally true for bandpass
    sampling, and so it sounded odd at first glance.
     
  16. miso

    miso Guest

    The impulse responses of anti-aliasing and reconstruction filters do not
    have to be related. These filters only have frequency constraints, as
    based on sampling theory, to avoid artifacts. Phase is another story.

    Simply put, I could anti-alias with an all pole filter or an elliptic.
    Both would do the job, but the individual impulse responses would be
    different.
     
  17. Les Cargill

    Les Cargill Guest

    I mean the impulse responses of a lowpass filter, a highpass and a
    bandpass of the same basic construction ( e.g, all three are an elliptic
    or Chebyshev or... ).

    Goes to your "colloquial vs. technical" comment.
    Quite.
     
  18. Les Cargill

    Les Cargill Guest

    Maybe I got lost :) but I thought we were talking about after a DAC.
    I just sorta rounded "anti-aliasing" up to being much the same
    thing as reconstruction in that role. Now, *those* are
    terms that get conflated constantly.
     
  19. miso

    miso Guest

    The schematic showed the filter going to an ADC. A differential one at
    that. So grounding one side and feeding the other through a rather high
    impedance resistor seemed to me to be a bad idea.

    You generally lose a bit of resolution on those differential input ADCs,
    so a differential drive is worth the effort.
     
Ask a Question
Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?
You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.
Electronics Point Logo
Continue to site
Quote of the day

-