Maker Pro
Maker Pro

LCR Meter Suggestions

D

Darol Klawetter

Jan 1, 1970
0
Can anyone suggest a good LCR meter? An industrial-quality instrument is preferred.
 
G

George Herold

Jan 1, 1970
0
Can anyone suggest a good LCR meter? An industrial-quality instrument is preferred.

We've got an SRS 720 that we use mostly for cap matching.. but also to
check coils sometimes. Frequencies are 100, 120, 1k, 10k and 100kHz.
$2k in my old catalog.

George H.
 
S

Spehro Pefhany

Jan 1, 1970
0
Thanks for the suggestion, but at $17K it's out of our budget.

What is your budget? What is your definition of "good"?

SRS has some nice retro-1980s styling ones for a few thousand.
SR715/720. They work okay for most purposes.

Or if you feel lucky you can get a real Chinese LCR bridge for a few
hundred. Or an LCR meter type thing for a hundred or so.
 
S

Spehro Pefhany

Jan 1, 1970
0
We've got an SRS 720 that we use mostly for cap matching.. but also to
check coils sometimes. Frequencies are 100, 120, 1k, 10k and 100kHz.
$2k in my old catalog.

George H.

Their Kelvin clips suck big-time unless you're exclusively dealing
with 1975 leaded parts with fat leads. The tweezers are better, but
still pretty MM for $300.

The bridge itself works fine (but don't get the model wrong or you'll
get stupid readings.. don't ask...).
 
G

George Herold

Jan 1, 1970
0
Their Kelvin clips suck big-time unless you're exclusively dealing
with 1975 leaded parts with fat leads.

Grin... yup, living on the trailing edge of industry.

But you are correct the input is clunky. I've used a few 'mods' on
the input,
including the dreaded white proto board.

George H.

The tweezers are better, but
 
F

Fred Abse

Jan 1, 1970
0
Can anyone suggest a good LCR meter? An industrial-quality instrument is
preferred.

HP4274A. I love mine.

Find one with Option 001 (0-35V DC bias), and the bias controller box.
You'll need that if you want to do anything meaningful with Y5V dielectric stuff.

Manuals are still on agilent.com. Take a look.
 
D

Darol Klawetter

Jan 1, 1970
0
Can anyone suggest a good LCR meter? An industrial-quality instrument is preferred.

Thanks to you all for the help. I'll consider your suggestions as I continue to define requirements for the meter. One requirement is that it be capable of measuring capacitance in the range from 1 pf to 10 uf, at 10% accuracy. Actually, I'll aim for the greatest accuracy I can get for a cost of around $500.

Darol Klawetter
 
Thanks to you all for the help. I'll consider your suggestions as I continue to define requirements for the meter. One requirement is that it be capable of measuring capacitance in the range from 1 pf to 10 uf, at 10% accuracy. Actually, I'll aim for the greatest accuracy I can get for a cost of around $500.

Darol Klawetter

Before you spend your hard earned money, you should look at http://aade.com/.
Neil was my lead way back in about ' 65. He is a really sharp
engineer. He has a page on some accuracy tests he did on measuring
inductors and capacitors with his meter and some other instruments.
It llooks as if you can exceed your accuracy requirements for
measuring L and C and only spend about $100. It will not get you to
10 ufd. But the web site is worth looking at even if you do not buy
anything.


Dan
 
J

Jamie

Jan 1, 1970
0
Paul said:
Darol Klawetter wrote:




Frequency range? 60 Hz, audio, MHz? Device parameters will change
significantly across these ranges.




10% is not much. I have a Radio Shack DVM that will do this on its
capacitance range. One can trade industrial quality for cheap enough to
drop and break occasionally. And just go out and buy another.

I have an LCR analyzer built around an AD5933 evaluation board. I think
those were selling for about $75 a few years back. But its home brew.
And don't ever buy this B model
http://www.amazon.com/BK-Precision-875B-Low-Ohm-Meter/dp/B000LDJ7L4

I had an "A" model which worked perfectly, incircuit and out, I would of
recommended it to any one. It got used and never returned back to me. I
had my employer get me another one. The "B" version replaces the "A" and
I can tell you it is a total re-engineered device that's not even close
to the quality of the "A" model.

It's intermitting at times when doing cap measurements and it has a
hard time doing in circuit testing. Not only that, you can not use each
scale to it's fullest, you have to select a scale that puts the expected
value at 50% or more, stated in the manual, otherwise no matter what
value you use it always seems to reach up around the 30% scale of min
reading, unless of course it is large enough to get into the working
area of the scale. I call that bad design work!

I had purchasing send that unit back for another, thinking it was
defective. Nothing could be that bad, but the new one came in and it too
was the same...

The basic Cap mode in my portable fluke (289) does much better than
this unit does for remote cap measurements.

I don't use it for serious work, it's a good thing I do have a more
serious unit to use for that.

Just another company and their products showing signs of the time (Greed).

Jamie
 
B

Ben Bradley

Jan 1, 1970
0
Thanks to you all for the help. I'll consider your suggestions as I continue to define requirements for the meter. One requirement is that it be capable of measuring capacitance in the range from 1 pf to 10 uf, at 10% accuracy. Actually, I'll aim for the greatest accuracy I can get for a cost of around $500.


I see some have denigrated some B&K models, but I have a BK878 LCR
I got 12 years ago, and I like it just fine. Claimed accuracy is
around 1 percent and capacitance resolution is 0.1pF, and it goes to
thousands of uF. Reads at 120Hz or 1kHz, displays dissipation factor
or Q, but not ESR (perhaps the main reason you might want something
else if you want to know ESR of electrolytics). There was an 878A with
RS232, and the current model is BK878B with USB, and still in the $250
range.
 
D

Darol Klawetter

Jan 1, 1970
0
Can anyone suggest a good LCR meter? An industrial-quality instrument is preferred.

Update: I decided to purchase the Agilent U1733C LCR meter. Moderately priced ($428) and HP/Agilent test equipment generally has excellent long term reliability. Again, thanks for all of the input.
 
Top