Connect with us

How easy to damage components through flow soldering?

Discussion in 'Electronic Design' started by Peter, Mar 2, 2007.

Scroll to continue with content
  1. Peter

    Peter Guest

    We have just had a delivery (from a pick/place subcontractor) of a few
    thousand populated circuits.

    Each one has a 22uF 50N Nichicon aluminium electrolytic cap on it, SMT

    I immediately noticed that all the caps have their top slightly bowed

    So I applied a 370degC temperature controlled soldering iron to the
    case of a fresh one of these. After a long time, after the cap was
    smoking away quite a bit, the top of it did indeed come up. Eventually
    it came up a lot more than those on the PCBs... yet, it still measured
    22uF-23uF with a capacitance meter.

    I am going to visit the contractor on Monday to see if we can work out
    what they did with their reflow oven to cause this.

    What concerns me is whether I should scrap all the circuits as a
    precaution. If I did that, what legal basis would I have for doing
    that? It would be hugely expensive, about US$20k.

    The rest of the components are some SO-14/16 chips, HP optoisolators,
    loads of ceramic caps, 0805 mostly but some bigger, melf (glass)
    diodes, plastic power diodes, etc.
  2. Brian

    Brian Guest

    Reply by email, perhaps I can help.
  3. Peter

    Peter Guest

    Reposted with my email address.

  4. Guest

    Do they work?? The ones I use look like that from the factory!
  5. Brian

    Brian Guest

    How'd it go at the manufacturer? We do quite a bit of lead free now. I
    know many manufacturers attacked it first by throwing lots of heat at
    it, NOT the way to go. Yes, I know Rohs is Bull-oni, but if you have
    to do it, might as well do it a best you can.

    Don't know if this is the problem in your case. hope you solved it.

  6. Peter

    Peter Guest

    I got a bit further now. The contractor had (without authorisation)
    reflowed that job using his lead-free oven profile, which is about 35C
    hotter. The temp profile is *just within* the published profile for
    that Nichicon capacitor (exceed 230C for 30s max, and 250C max) so I
    suspect the caps will actually be OK. They measure OK. I am waiting to
    hear from Nichicon for a confirmation; I sent them the oven profile.

    Their initial informal view was that a bit of gas pressure doesn't
    matter, so long as the thing doesn't blow apart...

    OTOH we do all remember that business from a couple of years ago when
    PC motherboard capacitors were "inflating" themselves all over the
    place, and losing their properties in the process. I think the cap
    value was OK but the ESR went sky-high.

    Unfortunately I can't measure ESR with anything I have here...

    The safest thing will be to rework all the circuits and change the
  7. Peter

    Peter Guest

    Yes, they work.
Ask a Question
Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?
You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.
Electronics Point Logo
Continue to site
Quote of the day