Dev kit for lots of PWM outputs?

Reply to Thread

Hello,

I'm considering an unusual embedded application which requires 250
simultaneous PWM outputs, all independent. I will poll digital
feedback values from each of the 250 devices (heaters) and use this
information to adjust the output duty cycles on a PID loop algorithm.
The chip would be dedicated to essentially this task only, with only a
handful of discrete I/O (start/stop signal & a couple of indicator
LED's).

Is there a single microcontroller that can do this? I looked at
Atmel, but there are so many possibilities and I'm afraid I'll waste
money on a development kit for a specific processor and then find out
that there was something better, cheaper, easier to learn, or more
appropriate.

Thanks for any leads you can provide.

Sid

 

Sounds like a job for an FPGA. You can probably make each pin its own
PWM channel. And you get get devices with up to several hundred I/O
pins.

You have several choices for the smarts:

1) hardwired computational structure in the FPGA (ugh!)
2) external processor controlling the FPGA (think an addressable
register for each PWM channel)
3) processor core packaged inside the FPGA package
4) processor implemented in the FPGA logic fabric

Basic Xilinx FPGA kit is about $100 from Xilinx or Digilent which
makes it for them. Their processor cores can't be implemented in that
chip but other people's can. Digilent also has NEXSYS with a much
larger chip for $120 - could be useful as you might run out of program
memory trying to squeeze things into the little chip (FPGAs don't
offer much memory compared to microncontrollers)

 

Use an FPGA as a PWM peripheral, all managed with one busy processor, or
find a modest processor that has a high PWM output to pin ratio, and use
as many as you need to get the job done.

I think I'd evaluate both solutions; I honestly don't know which one
would end up looking better.

--

Tim Wescott
Wescott Design Services
http://www.wescottdesign.com

Posting from Google? See http://cfaj.freeshell.org/google/

"Applied Control Theory for Embedded Systems" came out in April.
See details at http://www.wescottdesign.com/actfes/actfes.html

 

If I were to assume that your heaters are of a reasonable size then the time
constants involved are going to be in the order of minutes to tens of
minutes. As a result the bandwidth of the loop you use to control them can
be as slow as a slug with it's foot torn off.

Even with 250 of them on one processor you are not going to need
blisteringly fast speed. Not knowing much modern stuff I would suggest you
could dangle them all on an RS-485 cable running at 9600Baud.

Read back data for temperature then send a 4bit adjustment back to each one
for local processing with some shitty analog controller stuff.

One PIC for the central controller should do and another one for local
processing at the heater.

I could be wrong though.

Of course..... you could use an FPGA......?

DNA

 

I agree with sylvester. No modern microcontroller will have 250
separate input/output pins.
I believe that you need to use an FPGA in tandem with a
microcontroller. The FPGA handles the I/O and the PWM waveforms while
the microcontroller can do the maths stuff.

 

Heaters don't need that fast a response, and you don't actually need
PWM. You just need the current to be on some specified percent of the
time, right?

If you can find a CPU with enough general purpose I/O pins, try this:

For each pin, keep an 8 bit counter and an 8 bit "setting" value. At
regular intervals, add the setting to the counter, and if there's a
carry, turn the I/O pin on, else turn it off.

With this technique, you can do the math much less often (as slow as
one loop per second for heaters) and it "spreads out" the "on" pulses
(instead of lumping them together like PWM does). This is the same
technique used to draw angled lines, and similar to dithering and
sigma-delta.

 

Dear friend :
It is my fortunate writing to you . you will discover this is a wealth
accumulation place.
The website of our company is http://www.china-powerseller.com
We are a big agent for Laptop
Mobile Phone\Digital Camera\CDJ\DJM\Apple Ipod\PSP\VEDEO GAMES
\Television\GPS\Telescope in CHINA .
All of our commodities is the most advanced quality but lowest price.
we also have the

safest and most
convenient transaction way to guarante the transaction arries on
normally .
looking forward to your coorporation and cause all of us both to
profit.
you can contact us by Email:china.seller#hotmail.com
MSN: china.seller#hotmail.com
best wishes!
your sincerely

http://www.china-powerseller.com
MSN/Email:
The company this month is engaging in the activity! All projects Free
shipping expense.

 

FPGA, perfect for this
As much IO lines as you like.

 

Dear friend :
It is my fortunate writing to you . you will discover this is a wealth
accumulation place.
The website of our company is http://www.china-powerseller.com
We are a big agent for Laptop
Mobile Phone\Digital Camera\CDJ\DJM\Apple Ipod\PSP\VEDEO GAMES
\Television\GPS\Telescope in CHINA .
All of our commodities is the most advanced quality but lowest price.
we also have the

safest and most
convenient transaction way to guarante the transaction arries on
normally .
looking forward to your coorporation and cause all of us both to
profit.
you can contact us by Email:china.seller#hotmail.com
MSN: china.seller#hotmail.com
best wishes!
your sincerely

http://www.china-powerseller.com
MSN/Email: