M
Mook Johnson
- Jan 1, 1970
- 0
I'm having some problems specing out a data acquisition box that needs 4
4-20mA analong outputs and 4 4-20mA inputs. This is a custom box and so the
circuit design will be at the IC level.
Questions.
Receiver:
1) should it always provide power for the loop (13 - 40VDC)? nominal 30
VDC.
2) Should it sense current on the positive output of the powersupply or the
return (I've seen both ways)
Transmitter:
1) Always powered by the loop?
2) Common positive or ground? (or isolated)
The TX and RX are connected to a the same ground (all minus leads tied
together) that is electrically floating with reference to earth.
The issue is that I've seen implementations that go either way for which
side to sense and which current to control (positive draw with common return
or return current with common positive).
Currently the transmitters are simple darlington tranny pairs with an
emitter resistors and a opamp regulating the voltage drop across the
resistor to match its input voltage. (textbook ckt) the ground side of all
four emitter resistors is tied to the same board ground the input signal
(quad DAC) is referenced to.
This works well for a system designed for this operation but fall on it a$$
if the positives are tied together and the current is sensed on the return
lines (they all read the same due to current sharing).
The receiver is a simple 30V powersupply (referenced to board ground) with
four 100 ohm resistors fanned off the positive and difference amplifiers
measuring the drop from each one.
Again this does not work if the transmitters tie positives together and
attempt to regulate the retuen current. (current sharing again)
What do you guys recommend?
4-20mA analong outputs and 4 4-20mA inputs. This is a custom box and so the
circuit design will be at the IC level.
Questions.
Receiver:
1) should it always provide power for the loop (13 - 40VDC)? nominal 30
VDC.
2) Should it sense current on the positive output of the powersupply or the
return (I've seen both ways)
Transmitter:
1) Always powered by the loop?
2) Common positive or ground? (or isolated)
The TX and RX are connected to a the same ground (all minus leads tied
together) that is electrically floating with reference to earth.
The issue is that I've seen implementations that go either way for which
side to sense and which current to control (positive draw with common return
or return current with common positive).
Currently the transmitters are simple darlington tranny pairs with an
emitter resistors and a opamp regulating the voltage drop across the
resistor to match its input voltage. (textbook ckt) the ground side of all
four emitter resistors is tied to the same board ground the input signal
(quad DAC) is referenced to.
This works well for a system designed for this operation but fall on it a$$
if the positives are tied together and the current is sensed on the return
lines (they all read the same due to current sharing).
The receiver is a simple 30V powersupply (referenced to board ground) with
four 100 ohm resistors fanned off the positive and difference amplifiers
measuring the drop from each one.
Again this does not work if the transmitters tie positives together and
attempt to regulate the retuen current. (current sharing again)
What do you guys recommend?